Showing posts with label Swing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Swing. Show all posts
2009-12-15
GWT EventDispatch and widgets width and height
When you're constructing Widget in GWT - it's size is 0 until it's rendered. It's different from Swing, Swing assumed that you're working in EventDispatcher and calculated all sizes instantly. It is not announced but looks like GWT have it's event dispatcher too, and you can use DeferredCommand class to place Command into events loop. Using this approach you can construct Widget, place it into some Container, and then add some Command to DeferredCommand to work with widget's size after current construction operation will be complete and Widget will get it's size.
It looks like problem of all young widget toolkits, like Swing itself many years ago. They are showing it, its simple, its cool. But when you start coding real application using that toolkit - you'll get many problems, many different "hidden" features and many tricks and workarounds. After many years they'll tell you about EventDispatcher, then they'll implement different kinds of BackgroundWorkers, and different rules how to "use correctly" this toolkit. You can remember situation with "EventDispatcher rule" of Swing and how it was changed from Java5 to Java6 (while nothing inside was changed). Now we can see similar situation with JavaFX, and GWT goes the same way.
2009-12-10
Internationalization in UI toolkits
I have some experience with many different UI toolkits. The most with Swing, QtJambi, GWT, and some with SWT and Echo2. Some of them providing you with their own i18n techniques. Let's take a closer look...
Swing is the most comfortable tookit because it gives you full Java API, with source code, possibility to dive deep into it's internals and no external libraries or dependencies. And it gives you standard Java i18n engine: ResourceBundle. It's simple, powerful and effective. And it's customizable (if you know Java of course).
Qt Jambi gives you Qt's native internationalization engine. It works in other manner than ResourceBundles. API is clean and simple, every Qt widget have method tr(String) where you can specify default value, but not the key as ResourceBundle suggested. From one point of view it's good because you're hardcoding default values, and you will be sure that on any system it will at least show default version. From the other side - those messages can take a lot of space in your source files, plus they are actually keys in internationalization files, similar to properties files. Having keys like this is not very good, because modifying single char you have to modify all resource bundles, while in ResourceBundle you can leave code "as is", modifying only value but not key.
GWT is totally different. It's using properties files too, but you have to extend Constants interface, and add all your keys as String methods to interface. As for me GWT is the total winner, because you have properties files with key-value pairs and IDE support, and you have compile-time safety because you're getting those strings from Java class. In ResourceBundle you're operating mostly with Strings, and simple typo can waste lots of your time, while using GWT approach you must ensure your keys only once, then you're totally saved from any kinds of typos using Java methods to get your internationalized messages.
2009-02-26
Qt Jambi first experience
Being long time KDE user and Java developer - I couldn't ignore Qt Jambi release. Of course I downloaded it and tried as soon as version 1.0 vas released. Yes, at first it was version 1.0, built with Qt 4.3. Only after some time Jambi got version as its Qt.
I was impressed even with first version, but it seemed a bit slow and not yet ready for every day usage. But last week there were some news about Qt 4.5 and LGPL license, so I downloaded last available version of Jambi and started few example apps.
And now I am really impressed! I used to think about Swing as fast and developer-friendly when developing some desktop applications, but now I know Qt is really two heads higher in desktop apps development. Jambi evolved and now there is no problem of setting LD_LIBRARY_PATH and other params, you can simply include jar file with Qt and Jambi libs to your classpath.
Then I started a bit bigger project to have complete application in Jambi. As long as there is no fast and stable notepads for Windows I wrote QEdit. You can see sources here.
Now, after I have some first experience with Jambi I can compare Jambi and Swing:
+ Jambi has better shortcuts system. You don't have to work with root panes and actionmaps, you can just ass some shortcut to your action.
+ QStatusBar. I thought about writing something similar for Swing few month ago, but here you can assign statusTip to your action and that tip will appear in status bar on rollover.
+ QSettings. It is much more usable than Properties for storing your settings.
+ QToolBar. Even if it is possible to do something similar in Swing - you will never spend so much time to do it like Qt can. You can download and run QEdit to see how you can move toolbars to different parts of main window and this position will be saved between sessions.
+ QFontDialog. Almost every Swing application have to implement Font Chooser themselves, while QFontDialog is almost the same in every application.
+ Components already have their scrollbars, you can just enable or disable them. I can't remember at least one case when you don't need to wrap JTextArea into JScrollPane.
+ Wide range of supported graphic formats and components adjust size of graphic automatically.
- Jambi can't see if wrapped C++ classes extend some other classes.
- Jambi QFile is very slow and locking file. I don't like when File object locks real file on file system, only io operation should block it. So don't try to use Qt Jambi for all your tasks at once.
- No way to extend or customize QFileDialog. Even style is not applied to QFileDialog.
- Signals in "action system"... It's just wrong in Java. Thanks that application fails on first start but not in time of invocation if something is wrong in source.
- You can't give both small and large icon to QAction. After providing 22x22 icons some of them looks too smooth in main menu.
- Lack of documentation. If you are not enough documentation and examples from Jambi distribution - even Google will not give you a lot.
- Looks like all the work is performed in blocking QApplication.exec() method. I can't find is there anything like SwingWorker for Qt or Jambi...
- There are lots of possible pitfalls when you are writing huge application, and Swing "experience base" is huge enough to help you in almost everything, plus Swing is pure Java where you can debug everything you want. But where to go with Jambi? There is support in Trolltech for commercial version...
2008-11-07
Swing and TreeTable component
TreeTable combines functionality of two components - Tree and Table. And it is really comfortable to show some hierarchical information like file system structure or many others.
TreeTable have great Qt implementation, it's fast, useful and pretty. It's a pity there is no standard Swing implementation of this component. But there are lots of third-party implementations. Let’s review them:
JEdit
JEdit uses TreeTable component for Open-Save dialog. It is extremely fast and pretty. But they did it for their own, with package-private constructor and double-linked to other JEdit components. To use it in other projects means to rewrite it almost from scratch, so JEdit is just a good demo of TreeTable possibilities for Swing.

SwingX
SwingLabs has their implementation. It is feature-rich and customizable. But it has some rendering bugs, much slower than JEdit version, amount of code is too big to extend it yourself and it linked a lot to other SwingX packages.

NetBeans
As Tim Boudreau told us, NetBeans only recently got a good implementation of TreeTable. And this implementation looks great! It works almost as fast as JEdit one, has no rendering bugs, needs only few classes to build it (but not all the framework as previous two implementations) and it's easy to use and customize. But one more problem - you may use it only under either GPL2 or CDDL, and you need to download NetBeans sources and copy org.netbeans.swing.outline package to your project to use it.

All of them extends JTable. I think it's not good, JTable is the biggest class I have ever seen, about 9000 lines of code, and SwingX implementation adds another 4000 lines. It is hard to debug and hard to customize to internals. Swing is so big because backward compatibility, but what sense of JTable compatibility for totally new component? How do you think, may be it is time to write Tree, Table and TreeTable LGPL implementation by ourselves using best practices from core swing, SwingX, JEdit and NetBeans?
2008-05-21
LookAndFeel chooser
You will not dispute that modern desktop application needs some theming, right? And, being Swing developer, few times you tried to solve this problem, didn't you?..
I have solution now: JLAFChooser.
Now, you can just put JLAFChooser component into your setting dialog, and it will make LookAndFeel chosing possible in runtime. Now you have no need to hardcode all the LookAndFeels you know into your classes or XML files, and user can just download few LookAndFeels and put it somewhere in classpath to make it available to JVM.
It has two main variants: when Apply is allowed and when not.
When Apply is allowed your user can choose something from list and check it at once, and may be choose something else.

When Apply IS NOT allowed you can just show list of possible LookAndFeels, and save somewhere to preferences user selection, to apply it next startup.

Usage is similar to JColorChooser, with few extensions - you can get LookAndFeel instance, it's name or it's class name. Methods to apply and restore LookAndFeel are public, you may use them for your controls.
PS: feel free to mail me for suggestions, bugs, or just to talk about Java, Swing, religion, fantasy or anything...
I have solution now: JLAFChooser.
Now, you can just put JLAFChooser component into your setting dialog, and it will make LookAndFeel chosing possible in runtime. Now you have no need to hardcode all the LookAndFeels you know into your classes or XML files, and user can just download few LookAndFeels and put it somewhere in classpath to make it available to JVM.
It has two main variants: when Apply is allowed and when not.
When Apply is allowed your user can choose something from list and check it at once, and may be choose something else.
When Apply IS NOT allowed you can just show list of possible LookAndFeels, and save somewhere to preferences user selection, to apply it next startup.
Usage is similar to JColorChooser, with few extensions - you can get LookAndFeel instance, it's name or it's class name. Methods to apply and restore LookAndFeel are public, you may use them for your controls.
PS: feel free to mail me for suggestions, bugs, or just to talk about Java, Swing, religion, fantasy or anything...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
